10.11.2026
The elections that were not elections
On Friday I told the first half of that 2010 piece: that the Spanish yatra’s misfortune rested on a quality of its members, blind submission. Today the other half, the one nobody wants to hear, because it isn’t about the people in charge.
It’s about everybody else. About us.
Because in that post I didn’t spread the blame across two places but three, and the third was the rank-and-file devotees. And what I charged them with was this: that they didn’t unite, that there was personal ego, and that the elections were controlled from above.
Notice those three don’t weigh the same. The third is somebody else’s fault. The first two aren’t.
The elections part is easy to tell. When any local decision can be overturned from above, voting is a formality: you choose whoever you’re allowed to choose and the result stands if it suits. That turns the vote into theatre, and the voter knows it, and so he votes without believing it.
But look at the real consequence, which isn’t that the wrong candidate wins.
It’s that when voting is useless, people stop having opinions. Not stop saying them: stop having them. Why hold a view about how this ought to work, if holding it changes nothing and marks you besides? And after a few years you have a whole community with no formed judgement, not because it isn’t capable, but because judgement atrophied from lack of use.
And that’s where the other part comes in, the ego and the failure to unite, which was the part I had to look at myself.
Because those of us who did have opinions didn’t unite either. Each with his project, his group and his share of the right. And this has to be said plainly: a divided base isn’t a victim of centralisation, it’s its best argument. If nobody below can agree, then somebody has to decide from above, and that sentence writes itself in any meeting.
The text has a verse that in a case like this is almost irritating, because it apportions no blame:
A man must elevate himself by his own mind, not degrade himself. The mind is the friend of the conditioned soul, and his enemy as well.
Bhagavad-gītā 6.5. 1972 edition.
By his own mind. Not by reforming the statutes, nor by the twenty-year incumbents leaving, nor by clean elections.
And the second sentence is the one that still stings: the same instrument does both jobs. The head that gets you out of this is exactly the one keeping you in it, depending on what it’s occupied with.
What I proposed in 2010 is still reasonable and today I’d put it in a different order. Local self-sufficiency first, because it’s the only thing that needs no permission: a programme that pays for itself can’t be closed down from a meeting. And elections afterwards, which only make sense when there’s something real to direct.
But the true order starts earlier, and smaller.
It starts with having your own opinion about one concrete thing and holding it for two years without anybody confirming it. That is what was broken and that is what no org chart repairs. And it doesn’t take many: it takes three people who agree about one single thing and hold to it after it stops being exciting.
Sixteen years later, what surprises me most about that piece is how little it talked about work.
It talked about structures, about power, about who decides. And it turns out that everything that worked afterwards — and something did — came out of no meeting at all. It came out of people who got on with their own thing without asking permission, and who, when asked on whose behalf they were working, had nobody to name.