07.10.2026
Why I don´t read/post to Sampradaya Sun anymore
In August 2011 I stopped writing for the Sampradaya Sun, and I said why.
I had sent in an article and it was turned down. At first I thought it was the grammar — I write in English and it isn’t my language — so I exchanged emails with Rocana dasa, the editor, assuming it could be fixed by correcting.
It wasn’t the grammar. The objections that kept coming back spoke of a lack of clarity, of logical inconsistencies, of my not being specific enough. And read together and calmly, what they said was something else, which is how I put it at the time: pure censorship on concepts that they are not in agreement with.
The distinction matters, because they aren’t the same thing. Correcting is you saying your own thing better. The other one is you saying theirs.
What I was asking for wasn’t to be published with mistakes in it. It was that they publish my point of view and let the reader decide. And there’s the line out of all that which I’d keep:
“Let people judge by themselves, they are not children, and you are not their parent.”
Because that is what sits underneath an editor who rewrites your ideas instead of arguing with them: the conviction that his reader can’t bear to read something and decide. That it has to be handed over pre-chewed, and boned.
I also said that an istagoshti — a conversation among devotees — has to admit different points of view, and not only “spotless shastric” material. And I still think so, with one added reason I didn’t see in 2011: the spotless doesn’t get argued with, and what doesn’t get argued with doesn’t get learned. A publication where everything fits isn’t an orthodox publication; it’s a publication with no conversation in it.
And I closed by saying I have many more things to do apart from writing my views. I stand by that too, although today I know it was half true: the other half was that I’d had enough.
What I couldn’t see then is which side the text takes on this, and it turns out to be quite clear. Because the Bhagavad-gītā is the ultimate teacher explaining the most confidential thing there is to a disciple, at the worst possible moment, with an army in front of him. And when he finishes, after seven hundred verses, he does this:
Thus I have explained to you the most confidential of all knowledge. Deliberate on this fully, and then do what you wish to do.
Bhagavad-gītā 18.63. 1972 edition.
Do what you wish to do.
Notice who says it and to whom. This isn’t an editor with a newsletter: it’s Krishna, with Arjuna in front of him, and with every bit of the right on his side. He could close that sentence with an order and there would be nothing to object to.
And he doesn’t close it. He puts two things first: deliberate — think it through yourself, all of it — and then the decision, yours.
So whoever rewrites your concepts so the reader won’t get confused is being more protective than Krishna was with Arjuna. And I’m not pulling that comparison out of context: it is literally the scene.
What I learned from it, and it holds for anywhere that publishes you or stops publishing you, is three things.
One: ask early whether what’s coming back at you is correction or content. You can tell fast — correction can be accepted in full and the piece is still yours.
Two: the clarity argument is the hardest to rebut and the easiest to use as cover, because nobody can prove it was clear.
And three, the one that took me longest: you shouldn’t stay. If the place exists so that things don’t get argued, your article doesn’t belong there, and fighting for it concedes the idea that the place is the one that matters.
Fifteen years later, this letter goes out from a server that is mine, with no editor. That is the continuation of that business, and I hadn’t realised it until today.