First Hand

What I've lived and what I went and checked. One email a day, Monday to Friday.

JUAN MANUEL FERRERA

13.10.2026

When the money arrives before the people

On Friday I set out what I wrote in 2011 about New Vrajamandala. Today it’s only the principle I drew from it, because it isn’t about farms or about ISKCON: it holds for anything you try to build with other people.

Here it is. If the money arrives before the people, the project is already lost, even when the money is enough.

You’ll have seen the scene. There’s some small thing half working, held up by four volunteers and a borrowed room. A donor appears, or a grant, or a partner with funds. And within six months there are refurbishments, signage and somebody hired to coordinate.

And within eighteen months not one of the four is left.

They didn’t leave angry. It’s duller than that: they stopped being necessary. Before, if they didn’t turn up on Saturday, it didn’t open. Now it opens anyway. And nobody lasts long doing for nothing something that’s already covered.

I wrote then that I’d accept big money in only three cases: printing books, distributing prasadam en masse, and a genuine emergency — something legally dangerous or a matter of public health. And that for everything else it was better for the people there to organise it, even if it came out smaller.

Notice what those three cases have in common: not one of them replaces anybody’s work. Book money buys paper, it doesn’t buy the man who hands them out. Emergency money pays for a roof that’s falling in, it doesn’t pay for the enthusiasm of getting up there. They’re the three ways of putting money in without taking anyone’s part away.

And now the reason that isn’t economic, which is the one that interests me.

We usually thank whoever puts up the money, and we should. But it’s worth looking at what gets bought by accident. Whoever finances decides, even when he promises not to, because the man paying for the refurbishment has a legitimate opinion about the refurbishment. And the moment somebody outside decides, the one inside — the one who lives there, who might have said “this is mine” — steps back. Not out of pride: because he’s no longer needed.

That’s what I meant by letting them cook their own beans. It isn’t distrust of the man helping. It’s that participation can’t be bought, and it’s the only thing that really holds anything up over ten years.

The text, which has a good deal to say about giving money, doesn’t treat it as good in itself. It classifies it:

That gift which is given out of duty, at the proper time and place, to a worthy person, and without expectation of return, is considered to be charity in the mode of goodness.

Bhagavad-gītā 17.20. 1972 edition.

Four conditions, and not one of them is the amount.

Out of duty — not for the pleasure of giving, nor for how it feels to give it. At the proper time and place — which is the one that nearly always fails: the right money three years too early does damage. To a worthy person — not to the loudest project. And without expectation of return, where return isn’t only money back: it’s also the gratitude, the plaque, the influence and the opinion about how things should be done.

What sits underneath all of this, and I said it bluntly in 2011, is a question of faith. I wrote that I could already hear some of them laughing: they’re the ones who don’t have faith that Krishna will feed us tomorrow if today we spend everything we have for Him. And that such people shouldn’t be organising anything, but rather keeping the books or raising funds for specific projects, which is their proper work.

Because a man who doesn’t believe this holds itself up will juggle the economics to prop up a movement that runs on something else:

But those who worship Me with devotion, meditating on My transcendental form—to them I carry what they lack and preserve what they have.

Bhagavad-gītā 9.22. 1972 edition.

What they lack. Not what they want, nor what they had budgeted: what is lacking.

Fifteen years later, the only thing I’d add is a way of checking this without arguing philosophy. Before accepting the money, ask what work somebody stops doing if it comes in. If the answer is “none”, go ahead, and with gratitude. If the answer is “the work of the ones who were already there”, then you know what’s coming, and next year don’t say you can’t understand why nobody’s left.

Better a small and humble effort with a genuine spirit of service than a large project based on money alone.

All the cards