18.11.2026
What qualifies a man to instruct
In March 2010 I wrote about the return of Bhagavān das and his new way of presenting himself.
I wrote that piece angry and it shows: there were ironies and a couple of low blows. I withdraw the blows; not because they were untrue, but because they weren’t needed and they spoiled the only thing in there worth keeping, which was a question.
The question is this: what qualifies a man to instruct another?
The case that raised it was concrete. A man who had been a sannyāsī, who couldn’t sustain it, who left for twenty-four years, and who returns in a position to teach. I asked then, and I still ask with no bitterness at all: what sādhana qualified him during those twenty-four years? That isn’t rhetorical. It’s literally the question to ask, and it has a possible answer: there may be one, and if there is, it gets said and that’s the end of it.
What does still seem to me serious isn’t his biography. It’s the doctrine.
Because what that new identity was telling his followers, boiled down, is: you don’t have to follow anything; I tried and I couldn’t, and you won’t be able to either.
And that has to be looked at slowly, because it sounds like humility and is the opposite.
It sounds like humility because it starts with a confession, and a confession disarms. But look at what the second half of the sentence does: it turns a personal experience into a general law. From “I couldn’t” you move to “it can’t be done”, and nothing authorises that jump. It’s the same move as the man who drops out and explains that qualifications are worthless.
And notice how comfortable it is for both parties. It absolves the speaker of his past. And it absolves the listener of his future. That’s why it works, and why there will always be an audience: it’s the only doctrine that asks nothing of anybody.
What I pointed out then, and it was the good part of the piece, is that our ācāryas describe the qualified leader as one who controls the six urges, and that those urges are controlled by sādhana. So the qualification isn’t a title or a story: it’s a sustained practice, and it shows.
And there’s a Sanskrit phrase I used there which wasn’t an insult but a citation — śāstra-vidhim utsṛjya, discarding the injunctions of scripture. It’s in chapter sixteen:
But he who discards scriptural injunctions and acts according to his own whims attains neither perfection, nor happiness, nor the supreme destination.
Bhagavad-gītā 16.23. 1972 edition.
Notice what it does not say, because that’s what makes this verse usable and not a cudgel.
It doesn’t say the man who acts on his whims is wicked. It says nothing about his character, his past or his motives. It says something technical: that way doesn’t arrive. Not at perfection, not at happiness, not at the supreme destination — and notice it includes happiness, which is exactly what the easy road promises.
And that is the only thing that can be said with authority about another man: not what he is, but where what he proposes leads.
Sixteen years later, here’s what I’d do differently, and it holds for any similar case.
First: separate the man from the doctrine, and argue only the doctrine. The biography of whoever is speaking is his business and his teacher’s; what he teaches is everybody’s business, because it’s going to reach people.
Second: don’t use his fall as an argument. That somebody couldn’t sustain something proves nothing about what he teaches today, and using it is convenient and it’s dirty.
And third, which is what I learned by writing that piece: when you finish a text about another person and you feel pleased with yourself, don’t send it. That pleasure is the warning that you’ve changed subject without noticing, and that you’d stopped defending the śāstra some time back.
The question still stands and it’s a good one. What was superfluous was the tone.