12.11.2026
When one person holds the money
In April 2010 I wrote a post I titled “unspeakable secrets of the Spanish yatra”. Today I’m not going to repeat it, and I’ll explain why.
That text had two kinds of material mixed together, and at the time I didn’t separate them.
One was what I’d lived: offering technical improvements that weren’t welcome and finding the door shut afterwards; and paying a hundred and fifty euros over the odds on a shipment of books for something that a trip to the post office would have solved.
And the other was what I’d been told. A devotee who worked there confirmed to me that things were being delayed on purpose. I didn’t see that. I wrote it as though I had.
A few weeks ago I set out here what happens when a story passes from mouth to mouth: that it improves as a tale and deteriorates as information, and that whoever repeats it hands out something that isn’t his. I wrote that the question to ask isn’t whether it’s true, but how many hands it has passed through.
I’m applying that rule to myself today, sixteen years late. The names I put in that post stay in that post.
What can be told, because it doesn’t depend on who it was, is the mechanism. And the mechanism is always the same and requires no bad people.
A volunteer organisation where one person holds the money ends badly. Not sometimes: always, and for reasons that have nothing to do with that person’s honesty.
First, because whoever holds the cash ends up deciding, even without the authority to decide. He never has to say no to anything: it’s enough for something to be complicated, or badly timed, or “not this month”. It’s the cleanest form of power there is, because it never leaves a record of a refusal.
Second, because in a house with no public accounts everything suspected is unprovable in both directions. Neither can the suspicious party prove anything, nor can the suspected party clear himself. And that’s the unfair part I didn’t see in 2010: a lack of transparency doesn’t only protect the man who steals, it also condemns the man who doesn’t. Public accounts are the only thing that lets an honest person demonstrate that he is.
And third, because where there’s no channel for saying things, things get said anyway, only underneath. That’s what any institution’s “unspeakable secrets” really are: not restricted information, but what people say in the kitchen because there’s no meeting where it can be asked out loud without being marked for it.
A place with secrets doesn’t have a secrets problem. It has a meeting problem.
The text describes where that road goes, and describes it not as a crime but as a condition of mind:
They believe that to gratify the senses unto the end of life is the prime necessity of human civilization. Thus there is no end to their anxiety. Being bound by hundreds and thousands of desires, by lust and anger, they secure money by illegal means for sense gratification.
Bhagavad-gītā 16.11-12. 1972 edition.
Notice the order, because it runs opposite to how we tell it. We start with the money: he kept this, he charged that. The verse starts much earlier, with a belief — that this here is all there is — and puts the money at the end, as a consequence.
And there is the difference between gossip and a diagnosis. Gossip points at a man. The verse describes a state anybody can fall into, including whoever is writing the blog post.
What I’d do today, and it’s the only actionable thing in all of this, fits into three items and requires accusing nobody: that everybody sees the accounts every month, even if they’re four figures; that whoever signs off a cost isn’t the one who approves it; and that a meeting exists where asking costs nothing.
With that, unspeakable secrets disappear by themselves, because they lose the place they were living in.
And one more thing, which is for me. I wrote that post hurt, and it shows in the title. The hurt was legitimate. The title wasn’t: it promised revelations, when what was needed was something far duller, which is three columns on a spreadsheet.