First Hand

What I've lived and what I went and checked. One email a day, Monday to Friday.

JUAN MANUEL FERRERA

06.11.2026

Why doesn't the Spanish yatra get going?

In May 2010 I wrote about why the Spanish yatra wasn’t getting going, and I spread the blame across three places: the international GBC, the leadership here, and the rank-and-file devotees.

Of the three parts, the one that still seems true to me sixteen years later is the middle one, and not for what it says about the leaders. For what it says about everybody else.

I wrote this: the great misfortune of the Spanish yatra has rested precisely on a quality of its members: blind submission to authority.

Notice how the sentence is built, because it isn’t an insult. It says “a quality”. The misfortune didn’t come from a defect: it came from a virtue, or from something we’d all learned to treat as a virtue.

Because the Spanish devotee of those years was obedient, humble and trusting, and those three things are good. The problem is that all three together, without a fourth, produce exactly what they produced: splendid people incapable of saying no.

And the fourth that was missing is one’s own judgement. Which isn’t distrust, or rebellion, or wanting to be in charge: it’s having something to check against.

About centralisation I wrote what I still think: that above, it was decided that what Śrīla Prabhupāda did and said on matters of organisation was obsolete and had to be changed. And that can be argued about. What can’t be done is not arguing about it, which is what happened.

There was also a very concrete detail I pointed at then that nobody named, because it looked like logistics: English. Whoever spoke English had access to what was decided abroad, and whoever didn’t heard what he was told. That isn’t a language: it’s a door, and whoever holds the key to a door has power even if he never asked for it. When all the information passes through three or four de facto translators, blind submission is no longer anybody’s choice. It’s the only option available.

And here’s the trap it took me years to see: blind submission isn’t humility. It looks extremely like it, and in a religious setting it gets rewarded the same. But humility is knowing you might be wrong, and that includes being able to be wrong by obeying.

The text, which spends its whole length asking that an authority be followed, also says where the brake is:

One should understand what is duty and what is not duty by the regulations of the scriptures. Knowing such rules and regulations, one should act so that he may gradually be elevated.

Bhagavad-gītā 16.24. 1972 edition.

By the regulations of the scriptures. Not by whoever tells you.

So the measuring rod exists and it isn’t a person: it’s the book, and it’s within your reach, and it’s in your language. The one who teaches you is indispensable for understanding it — the Gita says that twenty times — but what he teaches can be checked against it, and the man who really teaches wants you to check.

Notice what that changes. A devotee who has read knows when an instruction is an instruction and when it’s the preference of a man with a post. And he doesn’t need to argue: it’s enough for him not to be confused, and to do what needs doing even when nobody has ordered it.

What I proposed then was replacing leaders who’d been there too long, returning to the simple principles, making local programmes self-sufficient, and having elections that were elections.

Today I’d put it in a different order, and that’s why this piece doesn’t end where that one did.

Because if the problem were people, it would have fixed itself by now: nearly all of them have changed. And if it were statutes, it would be fixed by writing others.

What has to be done starts somewhere far less epic. Somebody has to read the book in his own language and draw his own conclusions, and hold them without being disrespectful to anyone.

That needs no permission, no meeting, no vote, and no yatra getting going.

And until that happens, no org chart is going to fix anything, because the org chart was never the problem.

All the cards