20.11.2026
"I tried and couldn't" is not an argument
The day before yesterday I set out where that question came from — what qualifies a man to instruct another. Today only the doctrine, because it doesn’t belong to one man: it’s everywhere, and it’s probably been said to you.
It takes this form: I tried and I couldn’t, so you won’t be able to either; you don’t have to follow anything.
It’s said softly and with sad eyes, and that’s why it’s hard to answer. It looks like experience, like honesty and like compassion.
Let’s take it apart, because it’s three sentences stuck together and only the first is true.
“I tried and I couldn’t.” True, and brave besides. Nobody can dispute that in anybody.
“So you won’t be able to either.” There’s nothing true left here. A sample of one isn’t a sample, and his failure says no more about your case than one man’s drowning says about whether the sea can be crossed.
“You don’t have to follow anything.” And this is where it stops being an opinion about himself and becomes an instruction for you, which is the only part I argue with.
What makes this doctrine so effective is that it absolves both parties at once. It explains the speaker’s past. It frees the listener’s future. Nobody loses in that room, and so there will always be an audience.
But look at what it does underneath: it turns one man’s failure into a property of the road. And that can’t be done, because the road hasn’t said anything; the one who spoke was him.
And there’s one more thing, more uncomfortable: it sounds like humility and operates as authority. The man saying “it can’t be done” is teaching. He’s issuing an instruction about what others should do, on the strength of a record of not having managed it. It’s the only position in the world where having failed qualifies you to direct everybody else.
The text asks precisely this question, and doesn’t dodge it. Arjuna puts it in full: what happens to the man who starts this and doesn’t finish — does he lose both this world and the next? And the answer is among the most emphatic in the whole book:
The Blessed Lord said: Son of Pṛthā, a transcendentalist engaged in auspicious activities does not meet with destruction either in this world or in the spiritual world; one who does good, My friend, is never overcome by evil.
Bhagavad-gītā 6.40. 1972 edition.
Does not meet with destruction. Not here and not there. That is: the man who tried and couldn’t did not lose, and what he did was not erased.
And in case any doubt remains, the chapter goes on to say what becomes of that unfinished effort:
On taking such a birth, he again revives the divine consciousness of his previous life, and he tries to make further progress in order to achieve complete success, O son of Kuru.
Bhagavad-gītā 6.43. 1972 edition.
Revives. What was done is still there, kept, and recovered.
So the text and the doctrine don’t disagree about the facts: both accept that there are people who don’t arrive. They disagree about what that means. For the doctrine, the man who didn’t arrive proves it can’t be reached. For the text, the man who didn’t arrive is halfway.
And that difference changes everything, because one says what was done was wasted and the other says what was done is never lost.
Two practical things, and I’ll leave it there.
The first, for when it’s said to you: don’t dispute his experience, which is his and is true. Dispute the jump. “I believe what happened to you; what I can’t see is how a rule for me comes out of it.” That ends the conversation without disrespect, and it’s also exact.
And the second, for the day when the man who tried and couldn’t is you. You’ll have that sentence in your mouth, because it’s the one that consoles. Don’t say it out loud in front of younger people.
What happened to you is yours. What can and can’t be done isn’t yours to decide.