16.11.2026
My challenge
In April 2010 I issued a challenge. It was short and I stand by all of it.
That every devotee make his home a temple.
It isn’t a metaphor or an exercise in imagination. It’s putting what you already have at Krishna’s service. Nothing more.
And the argument fitted in four lines, which is what I like best about it.
The house is already there. It doesn’t have to be bought, or rented, or have a campaign run to pay for the refurbishment: it’s there, and you’re already paying for it.
Eating has to be done. You cook every day of your life. On Sunday you cook a bit more, and that’s that.
Chanting — that’s fine as it is. It needs no premises and no permission.
And inviting people: well, inviting people.
That was the whole proposal. And I added a calculation that still seems to me the most uncomfortable part: that Spain ought to have dozens of temples, given the number of long-standing devotees there are.
Dozens. Not one big one in a capital city: dozens of houses.
It’s worth asking why that didn’t happen, because the answer isn’t laziness.
It’s that we’ve learned to think that God’s business needs infrastructure. A building, a registration, a board, somebody in charge and a budget. And since all of that is very expensive and very difficult, the practical conclusion of any reasonable person is that this isn’t something he can do, and that those with the means will do it.
And so, without anybody deciding it, half the devotees in a country take a seat in the audience.
And the text is blunt precisely here, in one of the most famous and worst-applied verses in the whole book:
If one offers Me with love and devotion a leaf, a flower, fruit a water, I will accept it.
Bhagavad-gītā 9.26. 1972 edition.
Look at the inventory: a leaf, a flower, fruit, water.
The four cheapest things in existence. All four can be found anywhere and not one requires money, permission or premises. With a shopping list, the verse is saying that the material minimum accepted is practically nothing.
And if that’s so — and He says it, not I — then the shortage was never of means.
Because notice where the requirement sits in that sentence: not in the leaf. In with love and devotion. The only thing that can be missing there is the thing that can’t be bought.
And the next verse shuts the other escape route, the belief that this is a practice for people with time:
O son of Kuntī, all that you do, all that you eat, all that you offer and give away, as well as all austerities that you may perform, should be done as an offering unto Me.
Bhagavad-gītā 9.27. 1972 edition.
All that you do, all that you eat. It doesn’t say “give me an hour”. It says that what you’re already doing changes recipient, which is exactly what I was proposing in 2010 and in the same words: put in what you already have.
Sixteen years on I’d add three things that practice taught me and that I didn’t put in then.
One: start with Sunday and with a fixed hour. A temple at home isn’t an intention, it’s an appointment. With no hour there’s no temple, there’s goodwill.
Two: invite people before you’re ready. Everybody waits to have it all in order and that day never comes; and the house tidies itself when you know somebody is arriving at seven.
And three: don’t give it a name. The moment it has a name, the questions start about whether you answer to anybody, whether you’re authorised and who gave you permission. It’s a dinner with kirtan at your house. It needs nothing more.
The challenge is still open, with the same sentence I closed it with then: if anybody has doubts, here I am.