First Hand

What I've lived and what I went and checked. One email a day, Monday to Friday.

JUAN MANUEL FERRERA

30.09.2026

Confusion

You have two letters on the kitchen table and you’ve been staring at them for three days.

The one on the left is medical school, with a scholarship. What you said you wanted at fifteen, when you read that thing about the brain and something clicked. What your mother tells people over lunch. The sensible one.

The one on the right is the conservatoire. Composition, half the fees. What you do at two in the morning when you can’t sleep and the equations have stopped saying anything and only a melody explains what’s happening to you. The one you haven’t mentioned.

Your phone won’t stop. Your mother: “the medical deadline is Friday, you’ve sent it, haven’t you?” You haven’t. Your best friend: “the conservatoire, obviously, science makes you miserable.” It doesn’t: you love it, just differently. Your partner: “whatever makes you happy!” And there you are, because what makes you happy is precisely the thing you don’t know.

And you think this shouldn’t be so hard. People choose degrees, cities and partners every day and don’t spend three months paralysed.

But look at what’s actually happening to you, because it isn’t what you think.

Indecision is “I don’t know which I want”. Confusion is something else: I don’t know which I am. And it doesn’t yield to the same tool.

Your problem isn’t medicine versus the conservatoire. It’s which of the two people in there is the real one: the one who reasons or the one who composes, the sensible son or the one you suspect you are. And since you’ve been told all your life that you have to be one thing, pick a lane and keep the story straight, stuffing everything you are into a single decision feels like cutting off an arm to get through a doorway.

The whole Bhagavad-gītā exists because this is happening to Arjuna. And he does something we don’t reward: he says it out loud.

Now I am confused about my duty and have lost all composure because of weakness. In this condition I am asking You to tell me clearly what is best for me. Now I am Your disciple, and a soul surrendered unto You. Please instruct me.

Bhagavad-gītā 2.7. 1972 edition.

Nobody tells him off for being confused. Nobody tells him to pull himself together, or that at his age he ought to know by now. He gets an answer, and the answer runs seven hundred verses. Because nothing can be taught to a man who thinks he already knows, and you’ve spent three days pretending you almost do.

And then there’s a second round, which nobody mentions. A chapter later, having asked for help and received it, Arjuna says this:

My intelligence is bewildered by Your equivocal instructions. Therefore, please tell me decisively what is most beneficial for me.

Bhagavad-gītā 3.2. 1972 edition.

He asked, he was answered, and he is more lost than before. That is allowed too. Real guidance doesn’t always simplify: sometimes what it does is show you the question was bigger than you thought. Your friend, your mother and your partner gave you simple answers, and not one of them helped, because you weren’t choosing a university.

And there’s a third verse, the one that moves where you’re standing:

The Supreme Lord is situated in everyone’s heart, O Arjuna, and is directing the wanderings of all living entities, who are seated as on a machine, made of the material energy.

Bhagavad-gītā 18.61. 1972 edition.

In everyone’s heart. Yours included.

And no, this isn’t “trust your gut”. It’s something rather less comfortable: that you’re trying to solve with your head a question that isn’t your head’s. You’re asking your intelligence to tell you who you are, and your intelligence is part of the machine, not the one driving.

So what’s left to do isn’t what you’re doing.

Stop gathering information: you have enough, and more data doesn’t cure confusion, it feeds it. Close the laptop and stop asking for opinions. Say out loud that you don’t know, the way he did — that isn’t giving up, it’s the prerequisite for learning anything. Sit for twenty minutes in silence, not to find the answer, but to stop drowning in everybody else’s: what directs the wandering is already in there, but you can’t hear a whisper while everyone is shouting.

And change the question. Not “which is better”, which has no answer, but which of the two leaves me more myself and not less.

When you call your mother to tell her, she’s going to ask whether you’re sure.

And the good answer is no. That sure you are not, but you’re clear. And that’s worth more than being sure.

One other thing, for what it’s worth: in three years you may be writing music about how the brain works, and nobody had to die. There was never a choice between the two. What there was, was the need to stop asking which of the two you were.

All the cards