02.11.2026
ISKCON Malaga?
Last week I set out why I stopped using the name. Today the other half: why I think this happens to all of them, and it isn’t bad luck.
In September 2010 I wrote that my beloved ISKCON had reached a state comparable to gangrene. I chose the word deliberately and I don’t withdraw it, because it describes the mechanism well: gangrene isn’t an attack from outside. It’s your own tissue dying because the blood stopped reaching it, and what kills isn’t the wound, it’s the spread.
And alongside it I noted a historical claim that is still the most serious thing in that post: no organised spiritual movement survives the departure of the ācārya.
That isn’t a complaint about particular people. It’s a regularity, and it can be checked by looking back: the organisation survives, the current doesn’t. The building remains, the name, the accounts and the festival calendar, and what’s missing is the one thing that couldn’t be inherited.
It’s worth asking why, because the failure isn’t where it’s usually looked for.
While the founder lives, everybody knows what the house is for. No org chart is needed to say it: somebody embodies it and can be asked. His authority doesn’t come from the post, it comes from the fact that what he says works and that he does it himself.
When he goes, what’s left is an entire structure designed to execute, and none designed to decide what for. And nature abhors a vacuum: what fills that hole isn’t an idea, it’s people. And since the hole is one of authority and not of work, it gets filled with the only currency left, which is the post.
Hence the other thing I noted, which is Prabhupāda’s and is the shortest and most exact sentence of them all: the venom is personal ambition.
Notice it doesn’t say the venom is bureaucracy, or centralisation, or money. Those are consequences. Bureaucracy is what ambition builds when it needs to divide itself up: boxes, ranks, permissions, procedures so that nobody does anything without going through somebody.
And the text has had that venom identified for five thousand years, by name and with its method:
The Blessed Lord said: It is lust only, Arjuna, which is born of contact with the material modes of passion and later transformed into wrath, and which is the all-devouring, sinful enemy of this world.
Bhagavad-gītā 3.37. 1972 edition.
Only. Krishna is answering a very specific question — what pushes a man to do wrong even against his will — and the answer is one single thing, not a list.
And look at the chain it describes, because it’s literally what you see in any institution in crisis: born of contact with passion, transformed into wrath, and devouring. First it’s wanting. When the wanting meets somebody standing in the way, it’s anger. And then priorities stop being the subject: people are, and the meetings stop being about the work.
What I concluded then still stands, and it’s humbler than it sounds: that a spiritual revolution of this magnitude cannot be achieved from a centralised ecclesiastical institution.
Not because institutions are bad. Because it isn’t the tool. An institution knows how to conserve, and it does that very well: that’s why the books still exist, and the temples, and the dates. What it can’t do is the other thing, the thing the ācārya did, which depends on people who don’t want anybody’s job.
Sixteen years later I’d make one correction to that text, and it’s against me.
That “gangrene” is a word that serves for diagnosis and for nothing else. You say it to somebody and he stops hearing the rest, which was the part that mattered. And if you really believe the venom is personal ambition, then the first question you owe yourself isn’t who has it.
It’s whether you were enjoying being right when you wrote that.