First Hand

What I've lived and what I went and checked. One email a day, Monday to Friday.

JUAN MANUEL FERRERA

29.10.2026

Inside or outside ISKCON?

In October 2010 I put the question in writing, because I’d been putting it to myself for years: is this done inside or outside?

And the first thing I did was split it in two, because they’re two questions and they get confused constantly.

One is operating within the society, even just using the name. The other is what one actually does: the work and the service performed.

On the first I wrote something I’d still sign: that I’d been through all those stages in practice, and that I recommended — more than recommended, urged — anybody working within it or using the name to stop as soon as possible.

For two concrete reasons, and neither is philosophical.

The first is that the machinery stops you as soon as you make progress. They won’t let you do anything outside their programme, and their programme is crippled. So long as you don’t advance, you’re no trouble.

And the second is that with the name you inherit what comes with the name: the court cases, the bad press, the whole history. You take on the liabilities of a brand whose assets you don’t draw on.

Everybody I knew who was achieving something was achieving it the same way: by individual effort or in small groups, dissociated from the bureaucracy. And mind this, because in 2010 it was misread and still is: that didn’t make them hostile to the GBC or to anyone. They were simply getting on with their own efforts.

On the second question there’s no doubt at all, and I wrote it just as plainly: the potency comes from following Śrīla Prabhupāda’s crystal-clear instructions, and in that sense one is inside Lord Caitanya’s movement, the real one.

So the answer I gave then was this: cut the umbilical cord with what has turned into a pseudo-religion, and carry on doing what we’re supposed to do.

With the practical consequences that has, which are small and concrete. If you print books, you can’t put the BBT logo on them. If you try calling yourself ISKCON, as I tried, it only gives you headaches.

And what I found on doing it was the last thing I expected: that nothing changed.

My activities weren’t going to change for calling myself a bhakti yoga centre or anything else. People don’t care about names. The result of the preaching isn’t helped or harmed by a name: it’s made by proper action and mentality.

And I wrote the sentence that today seems to me to have been worth the whole post: since I severed my emotional attachment to “authorities”, institutions and names, I’ve been doing much better in my practical service and my personal spiritual life.

With two things that could be counted: a preaching centre with a proper Sunday feast, and a hundred and thirty thousand books printed.

From Aindra Prabhu I kept a line that says it better than I did: this sankirtan revolution will go on with or without the Krishna consciousness movement.

The text has a verse that is exactly this argument, and settles it from the side nobody looks at:

The Blessed Lord said: One who is unattached to the fruits of his work and who works as he is obligated is in the renounced order of life, and he is the true mystic: not he who lights no fire and performs no work.

Bhagavad-gītā 6.1. 1972 edition.

Notice what it’s doing: it takes the label off one man and puts it on another.

The sannyāsī — the official renunciant, the one with the name and the cloth — isn’t the man who lights no fire. The renunciant is the man who works without clutching the fruit, even with no title at all.

So belonging isn’t conferred by the register. It’s conferred by what a man does and where he does it from. Which is exactly what I’d spent two pages trying to say, and it was said in the first verse of the sixth chapter.

Sixteen years later I’d add one thing, and it’s a warning to whoever leaves.

That cutting the cord only works if you really cut the emotional attachment, which was the word I used. If you leave and stay preoccupied — writing about them, measuring yourself against them, waiting for them to admit you were right — you haven’t left: you’ve changed seats in the same room.

The sign that it worked isn’t that you speak better of them. It’s that you speak of them less.

All the cards