First Hand

What I've lived and what I went and checked. One email a day, Monday to Friday.

JUAN MANUEL FERRERA

15.10.2026

Fragments of Unconscious Civilization, applied

In July 2011 I was reading John Ralston Saul and I kept noting down fragments that weren’t about ISKCON and described ISKCON.

Saul writes about the elites of modern societies. And what he says, boiled down to one sentence, is that when a sophisticated elite fails it doesn’t correct course: it manufactures an artificial sense of well-being and insulates itself from reality. It isn’t lying to everybody else; it believes it. That’s the mechanism.

And what I wrote alongside was what I could see: that the GBC had produced exactly that, a conformist society where corporate loyalty weighs more than anything else. Too much bureaucratic centralisation. Power answerable to nobody. Budget cuts in place of any real capacity to grow. And criticism, even the kind that wants to help, treated as a public-order problem.

What I proposed then is still what I’d propose now: decentralise to the regional and the local, recover the way things were organised in the early years, and grant legitimacy to the rank-and-file devotee. With a practical reason that convinces me more than any principle: in small groups people treat each other as people. In large structures they treat each other as posts.

And then there’s the line I closed with, which still seems to me the centre of it:

Constructive criticism is perhaps the devotee’s primary weapon for exercising his legitimacy — and the sad part is that in a corporate society conformity, loyalty and silence are what get admired and rewarded.

Now. Fifteen years later I have to add something I didn’t put in in 2011, and it makes this harder, not easier.

Because if you go to the text looking for backing on this, you find both halves in the same place, and in the same list. Chapter sixteen opens by enumerating the qualities of a man of divine nature, and there they both are:

The Blessed Lord said: Fearlessness, purification of one’s existence, cultivation of spiritual knowledge, charity, self-control, performance of sacrifice, study of the Vedas, austerity and simplicity; nonviolence, truthfulness, freedom from anger; renunciation, tranquility, aversion to faultfinding, compassion and freedom from covetousness…

Bhagavad-gītā 16.1-3. 1972 edition.

The list opens with fearlessness. First of all, before charity, before austerity, before study.

And seven lines further down, in the same list and with the same standing, is aversion to faultfinding.

Both are divine qualities. There isn’t a good one and a bad one. And that disarms both sides of this argument at a stroke.

To the man who keeps quiet because it isn’t convenient to point things out, the verse recalls that the first thing asked of a good man isn’t prudence: it’s to be without fear. Silence out of convenience isn’t humility, and calling it humility is the oldest trick there is.

And to the man who writes — to me — it recalls that faultfinding is a vice with a name of its own, and that the difference between reporting a problem and making a career of finding faults doesn’t lie in the facts, which may be identical, but in whether you’re enjoying it. If writing it makes you smile, it had stopped being constructive criticism.

So the test, and I apply it to myself before anybody else, is three questions.

If this got fixed tomorrow, would I be glad, or would I be out of a subject? Have I said it to the person, or only published it? And am I writing it with fear or without — because if I’m writing it out of resentment, the fear is still there, only in fancy dress.

Saul was right about the diagnosis: an insulated elite stops receiving information, and an institution that rewards silence goes blind in a way it can’t even notice, because what’s missing is precisely the thing that would have warned it.

But the remedy can’t be a society of faultfinders, which is the other way of seeing nothing.

The verse puts the two together because they go together: speak without fear, and don’t enjoy having to.

All the cards