First Hand

What I've lived and what I went and checked. One email a day, Monday to Friday.

JUAN MANUEL FERRERA

25.09.2026

Homeschooling: a valid option

In 2009 I wrote in favour of educating children at home, and I wrote it arguing. I was answering the usual objections one by one.

That the children won’t be socialised. That school provides splendid socialisation: thirty children of the same age, shut in together year after year, tasked with pleasing an authority they didn’t choose.

That parents aren’t qualified. And I asked then, and I still ask: do you know who your child’s teacher is? His character, how he lives, what he thinks? He’s a stranger, and you hand him what matters most to you without blinking.

I quoted John Taylor Gatto, thirty years a teacher, saying that genius is far more common than we imagine and that the system busies itself covering it up, because it rewards something else: holding data until the exam, and being docile.

Seventeen years later I’ve done the whole run. Eighteen years with my children at home, start to finish. And what I see rereading that piece is that the arguments hold up, but that they weren’t the important part.

Because the hard thing about educating at home isn’t the teaching. That turned out to be the small part. The hard thing is holding it up in front of everyone, one year after another, with nobody confirming that you’re doing it right. There are no marks. No report. Nobody telling you your child is where he ought to be. That, which never occurred to me to put in back in 2009, is what makes people give up.

And there’s one paragraph from that post I’ve always stood by, and it’s the one I’d keep:

This doesn’t mean home schooling is for everyone, and nobody claims it is. What we want is for a parent’s right to choose his children’s education to be recognised.

Notice that the title doesn’t say “the best option”. It says a valid option. That was the thing worth fighting for then, and it still is.

And on how learning actually happens, the text describes something that looks nothing like a classroom:

Just try to learn the truth by approaching a spiritual master. Inquire from him submissively and render service unto him. The self-realized soul can impart knowledge unto you because he has seen the truth.

Bhagavad-gītā 4.34. 1972 edition.

Three things, and not one of them is an exam: approach, ask, and serve. The one who learns is the one asking; nobody is questioning him.

And the teacher is a teacher for one concrete reason, which is in the last line: because he has seen the truth. Not because he holds a certificate, and not because somebody put him in front of a group.

That can happen in a school, and it does. And it can happen in a kitchen.

All the cards