First Hand

What I've lived and what I went and checked. One email a day, Monday to Friday.

JUAN MANUEL FERRERA

09.10.2026

Unsolicited advice on New Vrajamandala

In July 2011 I wrote a plan for fixing New Vrajamandala. Nobody had asked me for it, and I said so in the title: unsolicited advice.

I had a reason for writing it anyway. That summer the devotees of the farm elected me vice-president. The National Council intervened immediately to say I didn’t even belong to the ACK, so I could hardly hold a post. The previous temple president had made me a legal member of the temple, and the Council itself had accepted that. Never mind: they overrode the election and declared me persona non grata.

And I wrote the plan even so, because I’d spent the summer there effectively in charge of the temple, and I knew things you can’t know from outside.

The first, and it’s the one that surprised me most: the place ran almost by itself.

The Deities were consistently well served by the devotee in charge, and in the whole summer I didn’t have to intervene more than two or three times, and one of those was to arrange for the pujaris to be able to go out on sankirtan. The cows, the same: the man in charge treated them like queens and brought ideas of his own for their upkeep and expansion. Zero intervention, zero problems. General cleanliness held up on the service of the devotees who are always passing through, with no heroic effort.

The second: the farm carried no burden. No mortgages, no outside loans, so far as I knew. And the state of the buildings was nothing like as dramatic as it had been painted by the man who wanted to sell the place. Repairs were needed, yes, and the details went to the European GBC, but nothing that couldn’t be solved with time, dedication and intelligence. In fact people were already at it: one of the devotees, for one, with the wiring of a building.

I wrote a sentence then that I want to repeat here: remember this, use your historical memory, or the crooks always get their way. Because the emergency was being invented, probably for political reasons, and an invented emergency can be used to justify anything.

And the third, which is the real one. What was broken wasn’t the farm: it was the design.

The leadership had changed the ACK statutes, giving unlimited power to the National Council, so that any local election or decision is revocable from above. That has a name and I wrote it as it is: absolute power corrupts absolutely. With addenda that make the association ridiculously bureaucratic, compartmentalising devotees into castes the better to control them. The words sound open, but not a blade of grass moves without their sanction, and that bureaucracy takes the enthusiasm and initiative of anybody with it.

And then the other end of the same rope: Madrid was already a separate entity by then, a private religious institution, with no legal connection to the ACK or to ISKCON. So: everything centralised above, and everyone to himself below. Both at once, which look like opposites and are the same thing — nobody answers to the people next door.

My proposal fitted on one line: let the local devotees cook their own beans.

No large donations for large projects. Big money only for printing books, for mass prasadam, or for a real emergency: something legally dangerous or a matter of public health. Everything else organised there, by the people who live there, even if it comes out smaller and slower.

And the reason wasn’t the money. It was that outsiders making decisions is always followed by the same thing: the man who lives there, who might have identified with it and served, stops doing so. A project is only alive if it’s activated from within. There are plenty of people who’d like to control those facilities and have them “leased”, and that kills the real development even more.

The text has a verse that is exactly this, and it says it without mentioning farms:

It is better to engage in one’s own occupation, even though one may perform it imperfectly, than to accept another’s occupation and perform it perfectly.

Bhagavad-gītā 18.47. 1972 edition.

Even though one may perform it imperfectly. There’s the whole business. The plan from outside may be better on paper — more money, more repairs, better management — and still be the worse one, because it’s another man’s occupation.

Fifteen years later I haven’t changed my mind about any of this, and I’ll add one thing I didn’t say then.

That the efficiency argument always wins the meeting and always loses the project. It’s very easy to demonstrate that a crew from outside will fix the roofs sooner and better than four devotees with a summer ahead of them. What can’t be demonstrated in a meeting is the other half: that when outsiders fix the roofs, nothing grows inside any more.

All the cards